Exploring the Unknown: A Guide to Effective Exploratory Testing in Software
Image source:
Software testing, a critical phase in the development process, entails the meticulous search for errors within the product while ensuring alignment with anticipated outcomes. It serves as a pivotal step in identifying defects, verifying requirements, and ensuring a seamless user experience. Despite its paramount importance, many startups often disregard testing, citing budget constraints. However, neglecting this crucial step can have adverse effects on the product's reputation and viability. Hence, investing in robust testing mechanisms is imperative to establish a strong and favourable impression.
Exploratory testing represents a departure from conventional scripted testing methodologies. It empowers testers to delve into the product organically, without the constraints of predetermined scripts or test cases. This approach fosters creativity, enabling testers to simulate real-world scenarios and replicate end-users' actions. At Global App Testing, for instance, testers are incentivized to identify high-priority bugs, augmenting the efforts of the QA team.
What is exploratory testing?
Exploratory testing emerged organically in the early stages of software development, characterised by testers' intuitive exploration of software systems without rigidly scripted test cases. However, its formalisation and recognition as a structured methodology occurred in the late 1990s and early 2000s, largely due to the pioneering work of Cem Kaner and James Bach. They emphasised the importance of skilled testers using their domain knowledge, experience, and creativity to design tests dynamically based on their understanding of the software and its context.
As the Agile movement gained momentum in the mid-2000s, exploratory testing found renewed relevance due to its alignment with Agile principles such as adaptability, collaboration, and delivering value iteratively. This integration led to increased adoption of exploratory testing within Agile teams, where it became an essential part of the testing process.
The publication of "Exploratory Testing Explained" in 2009 by James Bach and Jonathan Bach served as a comprehensive guide to the practice, further legitimising its principles and techniques within the software testing community. This publication helped bridge the gap between theory and practice, making exploratory testing more accessible to testers and organisations worldwide.
Since then, exploratory testing has continued to evolve in tandem with advancements in Agile methodologies, test automation, and DevOps practices. Testers now leverage various tools and techniques, such as session-based test management, mind mapping, and exploratory testing charters, to enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of their exploratory testing efforts.
Today, exploratory testing remains a vital component of modern software testing strategies, enabling testers to uncover defects, explore system behaviours, and provide rapid feedback to development teams. Its adaptability and emphasis on human intelligence make it particularly well-suited for the dynamic and iterative nature of Agile and DevOps environments.
Exploratory Testing In Agile Methodology
Exploratory testing is an agile software testing technique in which a number of software testers look for bugs in an application without a script.
Typically, testers would use domain knowledge and their creativity to explore software seeking defects, vulnerabilities, and/or usability issues. Exploratory testing enhances test coverage and enhances the level of robustness of a QA approach.
Exploratory testing is particularly well-suited to Agile development methodologies due to its flexibility, adaptability, and emphasis on collaboration and rapid feedback. In Agile environments, where changes are frequent and the focus is on delivering working software iteratively, exploratory testing offers several benefits:
Adaptability to Change: Agile teams often work in short iterations, making it challenging to create detailed test cases upfront. Exploratory testing allows testers to adapt their testing efforts quickly in response to changing requirements and priorities.
Early Bug Detection: By allowing testers to explore the software in real-time, exploratory testing can uncover bugs and defects early in the development process. This early feedback is crucial for Agile teams to address issues promptly and ensure the quality of each iteration.
Collaboration: Exploratory testing encourages collaboration between testers, developers, and other stakeholders. Testers can work closely with the development team to understand new features and changes, identify potential risks, and provide valuable feedback.
Focus on User Experience: Agile development emphasises delivering value to users quickly. Exploratory testing allows testers to focus on user experience and usability, simulating real-world usage scenarios and uncovering issues that scripted tests might miss.
Continuous Improvement: Agile principles promote continuous improvement and learning. Exploratory testing fosters a culture of learning and experimentation within the team, allowing testers to continuously refine their testing strategies and approaches based on feedback and lessons learned.
Overall, exploratory testing enhances the Agile development process by providing rapid feedback, fostering collaboration, and ensuring that the software meets user expectations and quality standards.
PROS AND CONS
Exploratory testing offers several advantages and disadvantages, which can vary depending on the context and the specific needs of the project. Here's an overview of the pros and cons:
PROS:
Flexibility: Testers have the freedom to explore the software dynamically, adapting their testing approach based on their observations and findings.
Creativity: Exploratory testing encourages testers to be creative in their testing strategies, leveraging their domain knowledge and experience to uncover defects effectively.
Real-world Scenarios: Testers can simulate real-world usage scenarios, which may reveal defects that scripted tests might miss. This approach helps ensure that the software meets user expectations and behaves as intended in different situations.
Early Bug Detection: Exploratory testing can uncover bugs and defects early in the development process, allowing teams to address issues promptly and reduce the cost of fixing defects later on.
Efficiency: In some cases, exploratory testing can be more efficient than scripted testing, especially when dealing with complex or rapidly changing systems where creating and maintaining detailed test cases is challenging.
CONS:
Lack of Documentation: Since exploratory testing is often unscripted and ad-hoc, it may result in a lack of documentation, making it difficult to reproduce tests or track testing coverage over time.
Varied Coverage: The coverage achieved through exploratory testing can be unpredictable and may vary depending on the skills, experience, and intuition of individual testers. This variability can make it challenging to ensure comprehensive testing coverage.
Subjectivity: Exploratory testing relies heavily on the tester's judgement and intuition, which can introduce subjectivity into the testing process. Different testers may approach the same application differently, leading to inconsistent results.
Risk of Overlooking Bugs: Without predefined test cases, there is a risk that testers may overlook certain areas of the application or specific edge cases, potentially leading to undiscovered bugs slipping into production.
Time-boxing Challenges: While exploratory testing offers flexibility, it can also be challenging to manage time effectively, especially when time-boxing testing sessions. Testers may struggle to balance thorough exploration with time constraints.
Who Conducts Exploratory Testing?
Exploratory testing can be conducted by various team members, including:
Dedicated Testers: Testers with expertise in software testing and a deep understanding of testing principles often excel at exploratory testing. They can leverage their experience to identify potential issues and provide valuable feedback to the development team.
Developers: Developers can also perform exploratory testing, especially during the development phase. Their familiarity with the codebase and technical aspects of the application can help them uncover defects and verify that new features meet the expected behaviour.
Product Owners/Business Analysts: Product owners and business analysts can contribute to exploratory testing by validating that the software meets the specified requirements and aligns with the business goals. They can explore the application from a user's perspective and provide feedback on usability and functionality.
UX Designers: UX designers can play a valuable role in exploratory testing by assessing the user experience and interface design. They can identify usability issues, inconsistencies in design patterns, and areas for improvement to enhance the overall user experience.
Ultimately, anyone with a stake in the quality and usability of the software can contribute to exploratory testing. It's essential to involve team members with different skill sets and perspectives to ensure comprehensive coverage and thorough evaluation of the application.
How To Do Exploratory Testing?
Tools For Exploratory Testing
There are several tools available to assist with exploratory testing, offering features such as session management, note-taking, screen recording, and defect tracking. Here are some popular tools used for exploratory testing:
Session-Based Test Management (SBTM) Tools:
SessionStack: Allows testers to record and replay their testing sessions, capturing interactions, and bugs in real-time.
SessionTest: Facilitates session-based testing by providing a platform for organising, documenting, and tracking testing sessions and outcomes.
Note-Taking and Documentation Tools:
Evernote: Enables testers to take notes, capture screenshots, and organise information during exploratory testing sessions.
OneNote: Similar to Evernote, OneNote offers robust note-taking capabilities and integration with other Microsoft Office applications.
Screen Recording Tools:
Camtasia: Provides screen recording and video editing features, allowing testers to record their testing sessions, annotate videos, and share findings with the team.
OBS Studio: An open-source screen recording tool that offers customizable recording settings and live streaming capabilities.
Defect Tracking Tools:
Jira: Widely used for issue tracking and project management, Jira can be utilised to log and track defects uncovered during exploratory testing sessions.
Bugzilla: An open-source bug tracking system that enables testers to report, track, and manage defects efficiently.
Collaboration Tools:
Slack: Facilitates communication and collaboration among team members during exploratory testing sessions. Testers can create dedicated channels to discuss findings, share screenshots, and coordinate efforts.
Microsoft Teams: Offers similar collaboration features to Slack, including chat, file sharing, and video conferencing capabilities.
Browser Extensions:
Bug Magnet: A browser extension that provides testers with a set of common test data elements to populate forms quickly and uncover potential issues.
Session Manager: Allows testers to save and manage browser tabs and sessions, making it easier to resume testing sessions and document findings.
Mind Mapping Tools:
MindMeister: Enables testers to create visual mind maps to organise test ideas, explore different testing paths, and document testing strategies.
XMind: Another popular mind mapping tool that offers a wide range of features for brainstorming, planning, and organising testing activities.
These tools can enhance the efficiency, effectiveness, and collaboration of exploratory testing efforts, enabling testers to uncover defects, document findings, and communicate results more effectively with the development team.
HOW TO OVERCOME LIMITATIONS ?
Less traceability: In this testing methodology, testers do not follow any predefined test plan, test strategy, or test scripts. Also, its documentation is progressive. Hence, it lacks traceability which acts as a challenge. To overcome this challenge, testers should log the test as and when it is executed. Also, the test progress should be shared with stakeholders or fellow testers to keep them informed.
Lack of product knowledge: This testing type can be performed by individuals who lack product knowledge, but sometimes this can act as a challenge. Without a proper understanding of the product, there is every possibility of missing some important scenarios. Hence, in order to overcome this challenge, it is advised to include skilled testers in the testing team to perform this test. It is effective to leverage pair testing, where both testers should be highly skilled, or either one of them should be skilled.
Not knowing when to adopt exploratory testing: Another challenge in this testing methodology is that sometimes businesses don’t know the right time to adopt and implement it. Since this testing method lacks test cases and is a bit informal, it is not considered good for auditing purposes. Therefore, if implemented at the wrong time, it can have a negative impact. To overcome this challenge, businesses should leverage this test method to find bugs in the software when time is less. Once the bugs are fixed, this testing method can be used to verify those bugs on the fly. It should not be used for projects that need more. This special testing method is performed manually to a large extent, and its effectiveness depends upon human intelligence. But, as businesses continue to leverage test automation, there is always a question about whether it can be automated or not when it comes to exploratory testing.
Future Outlook
The future of exploratory testing in software testing looks promising, with several key trends emerging:
Integration with AI and Machine Learning: Expect exploratory testing to leverage AI and ML for tasks like test case generation and anomaly detection, enhancing efficiency and effectiveness.
Enhanced Collaboration: Tools facilitating real-time collaboration and remote testing will improve team communication, crucial for distributed Agile teams.
Automation Support: Automation will augment exploratory testing, handling repetitive tasks and providing data analysis support while testers focus on critical exploration.
Quality AI and ML Models: Integration of quality AI and ML models will enable better risk prediction and test scenario suggestion, improving coverage and defect detection.
Human-Centric Focus: Despite automation, the human element remains key. Future developments will likely focus on empowering testers' creativity, intuition, and domain expertise through training and development initiatives.
In summary, exploratory testing will continue to evolve, adapting to technological advancements and evolving development practices while remaining a vital component of software testing methodologies.
Conclusion
Exploratory testing emerges as a dynamic and indispensable component of the software testing arsenal. By harnessing its flexibility and harnessing human intelligence, teams can uncover defects, optimise user experience, and expedite product delivery. Embracing exploratory testing within a holistic testing strategy empowers organisations to navigate the complexities of modern software development with agility and efficacy, ultimately delivering superior products to end-users.
Dedicated software tester with a passion for ensuring flawless user experiences. Committed to meticulously testing every aspect of software functionality to guarantee quality and reliability.
We specialize in product development, launching new ventures, and providing Digital Transformation (DX) support. Feel free to contact us to start a conversation.
.svg)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.svg)
